What science says about cat litter: a summary of 5 studies
Which litter do cats like best? Do they like scents? Is bentonite dust dangerous? Can litter be flushed? We briefly summarise published studies and what they mean for everyday litter box care.
Key takeaways
- Activated carbon controls odour in a way that makes cats more willing to use the box, while strong floral and citrus scents may put them off.
- Soy by-products work well as litter: in the study they clumped well, created little dust and controlled odour.
- With normal use of bentonite litter, the risk from silica dust is considered low, but researchers stress that the topic needs further study.
- Only urine clumps of tofu litter should be flushed or composted. Faeces should go in a sealed bag with general household waste.
Cats prefer fine, clumping litter
Cat behaviour researcher Peter Borchelt compared which litter cats choose when given a choice. Cats clearly preferred fine, sand-like clumping litter over large granules. Later experiments by J. Neilson (2001) showed that clumping litter was also chosen more often than silica litter.
What it means: when switching litter, choose a clumping one and switch your cat over gradually, mixing new with old (see the 6-day plan).
Activated carbon and scents
Veterinarian and animal behaviour specialist Jacqueline Neilson studied around 32 shelter cats. The cats used boxes with activated carbon significantly more often than boxes with baking soda (sodium bicarbonate). In smaller scent trials, cats avoided citrus and floral scents.
What it means: in multi-cat homes, litter with activated carbon is a good choice. If your cat is fussy, start with natural, unscented litter and watch how they react to scents.
Soy by-products as cat litter
Scientists from the US Department of Agriculture (USDA) described a litter made from soybean hulls and soybean hull biochar in the journal Bioresource Technology Reports. The final formula absorbed moisture well and clumped as well as or better than four commercial plant-based litters, was better at controlling odour and dust, and reduced the levels of three pathogenic bacteria over three days.
What it means: soy by-products that would otherwise become waste can be a raw material for quality litter. The study used soybean hulls, while tofu litter is made from the soy pulp left over from tofu production, but both are plant fibres of the same origin.
Is bentonite dust harmful to people?
Bentonite litter contains crystalline silica. In an assessment presented at the 2025 Society of Toxicology conference in the US, researchers estimated how much silica dust a person inhales when scooping the box daily and replacing all the litter monthly over 12 years. Conclusion: with normal use, no significant risk to the respiratory tract is expected, as the dust levels are lower than typical outdoor air in the US. However, the authors note that cases of illness linked to bentonite litter have been reported, so more research is needed.
What it means: there's no need to panic, but if your home has babies, people with allergies or cats with sensitive airways, a low-dust litter is the safer choice.
Why cat faeces shouldn't be flushed
Scientists at the University of California, Davis, studied 116 dead sea otters in a paper published in Proceedings of the Royal Society B. 12 of them died mainly from the parasite Toxoplasma gondii, and in another 21 cases it contributed to death. The parasite is spread through cat faeces, and sewage treatment plants don't destroy its eggs (oocysts), so they can survive in water for months.
What it means: even if a litter dissolves in water, only flush urine clumps, one at a time. Composting faeces isn't recommended either: home compost rarely gets hot enough to kill parasites, and they can end up in your garden with the compost. Put faeces in a sealed bag with general household waste. Urine clumps can be composted if the compost is used for ornamental plants.
MorePet: clumping, low-dust tofu cat litter
Also available with activated carbon for multi-cat homes.
Sources
1–2. Borchelt P. L. (1991); Neilson J. (2001, 2007–2008). Summarised in: dvm360: The latest scoop on litter
3. Vaughn S. F. et al. (2023). Production of an odor-reducing, low-dust, clumping cat litter from soybean hulls and soybean hull biochar. Bioresource Technology Reports. ScienceDirect · USDA ARS
4. Bogar L., Yale K., Allen L., Burns A. (2025). Airborne silica from bentonite clay cat litter. Society of Toxicology 64th Annual Meeting. ToxStrategies
5. Shapiro K. et al. (2019). Proceedings of the Royal Society B. Summarised in: Smithsonian Magazine. On composting: Catpip: How to dispose of cat litter